Drowned in Sound

Search



bloc party album

Bloc Party: Silent Alarm

1 vote
?
by Gen Williams
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 14/02/2005
  • Label: Wichita
  • Tracks: 1 - Like Eating Glass / 2 - Helicopter / 3 - Positive Tension / 4 - Banquet / 5 - Blue Light / 6 - She's Hearing Voices / 7 - This Modern Love / 8 - Pioneers / 9 - Price of Gas / 10 - So Here We Are / 11 - Luno / 12 - Plans / 13 - Compliments

Who knew? Some bands explode into our consciousness with a flurry of publicity and a barrage of pop missiles. Others creep up on us over a matter of years. And then you get Bloc Party. About a year and a half ago this writer first glimpsed our heroes at a DiS gig, then named Union, and frankly, to her mind at least, they were not very good. They were a bit Sonic Youth-y, and a bit Strokes-y, as so many young bands seem to be, and distinctly lacking in style, identity or musical flair.

And then something sudden seemed to happen, and they changed their name, and set about morphing into one of the most exciting UK bands of the past two years, and that deep-ingrained, cunningly spotted potential burst forth. It's already somewhat a given that Bloc Party are going to do very, very well indeed. Yet all the angular pop pickings and fiery live shows in the world couldn't have prepared us for this record. The detractors who expected sixty minutes of Gang Of Four covers are in for a shock. Silent Alarm is a remarkably mature, expansive record. It's clear that Bloc Party have wanted to experiment from the word go; first step, turn down a Parlophone deal for a Wichita contract. Second step, fill your debut with weird noises and B-movie echoes, layered over compelling, jerky songs.

The singles are by no means the sole highlights on Silent Alarm. From the opener 'Like Eating Glass', it's clear that the bar has been set high. Shrill, grasping and desperate, its urgency sets the pace for the whole record, Kele Okereke's vocals ringing out like a frantic siren. 'Pioneers' is wordlessly gorgeous, and old single 'She's Hearing Voices' has been reproduced and tinted with a hollow, ghostly hue that replaces the original version's tinny sound. It's a trick that's echoed later on the soopafine 'Price Of Gas', arguably the record's peak; desolately urban, unsettling and alien, it's the sound of the Specials being methodically taken apart by Le Tigre, eerie two-tone rumblings being devoured by Okereke's peculiar, high-pitched and in places androgynous shouting.

Silent Alarm's not 100% filler-free - the forgettable 'So Here We Are' could have slipped out the back with little protest - but the autonomy, creativity and sheer, elastic beauty that spans this debut more than justifies the rapidly accelerating hype that Bloc Party are currently generating. Any of the lazy comparisons that initially dogged them are firmly laid to rest beneath the floorboards of Silent Alarm; if Bloc Party ever sounded like the Strokes duelling with Gang of Four, they don't anymore. Frankly in places this record sounds more like the Police (in a good way, mind), and sublime album closer 'Compliments' wears shades of Ultra-era Depeche Mode, saturnine and serpentine, winding languidly through the confines of your headspace. More than the sum of its influences though, it's an addictive, pulsing and innovative record that confirms Bloc Party's status as one of our most essential bands and showcases how exciting British music is capable of being right now.

  • Bloc Party 9 / 10

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Did it lose half a point for the cover?

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Yes, there's been some debate about that cover... fans of late nineties guitar slush might remember a record called THe Man Who... which is a horrible thing to say. So I won't say it. But let this be said instead: This is an amazing record.

Go bloc party.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Thats exactly what I was going you say you bugger! Damn it, I thought I was the only person who thought that, and people we going to say how clever I am and shower me in sweets and free contraceptives. Now, I must kill you, and die lonely in a field (not dissimilar to the one on the cover).

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Yeah but The Man Who cover was shot in Aviemore, which is where I'm from, so that makes it great, and it stares down at me whenever I'm in the Dublin Castle, which is my second home, as you know. Or is it my 4th home? Oh now I'm confused.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Hurrah! But Le Tigre? Interesting comparison, but I ain't sure myself. Although I'm sure Kele would like that reference.

That Le Tigre chic is hot isn't she?

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Err not really. Anyway Ad-Rock might have something to say to you about that.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Come on, have you not seen her in that Sonic Youth video? Although that was about 14 years ago. oops.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

What? No five stars for Bloc Party?

Gen, I think you may have written your last article for DiS. ;-)

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

haha!

to be honest i don't think i've ever encountered an album that quite deserved five stars - in the sense of me knowing that it would be a record i would love for all eternity, come hell or high water. what can i say? perhaps i have attention deficit disorder. yet i hold out hope that one day i'll find it...

xxx

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

you should only be able to award one 5 star and one 0 star in your life

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

i thiiiiiink the new trail of dead album may come very very close to that fabled five-star mark.

not quite close enough, but close nonetheless.

xxx

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Ah...cannae wait for this album! And they're actually playing in Reading too...somehow I get the feeling it's the last time we'll see them play the Fez Club...

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Spot on with that little lot Gen.
The Price Of Gas stands out as possibly the best thing Bloc Party have recorded to date and yet they haven't released it as a single, which beggars belief when you listen to 'So Here We Are'. Still, it says a lot for the high standard of their material when two of their best songs to date 'Little Thoughts' and 'The Marshals Are Dead' don't make the final cut for the album.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

yeah I was quite suprised by the lack of those songs...I am a listening to it now.....This Modern Love is excellent, as is Positive Tension. The whole thing isn't as immediate as I thought though

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

OK, this record is just bloody marvellous!!!

But I just wante dto point out thar "Price of Gas" is a little too close to Les Savy Fav for comfort. However, it's still a great tune and showing your influences is not a bad thing.

It isn't as immediate as I expected either and thet's a good thing as far as I'm concerned - you get the immediate fix of Like Eating Glass, Helicopter, Banquet and also the growers like Pioneers, Blue Light, Compliments = longevity.

About the only thing on this record I dont like is the harmonised guitar solo at the end of Plans. For me, that wrecks an otherwise delightful song - but hey, I just don't like harmonised guitar solos!!!

This album is wonderful.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

'So here we are' sounds like the ballad from Labyrinth, but not as good.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

main thing i cant see is:
wheres the crossover 'radio1 killer' single, ie razorlights golden touch, killers 'iv got soul, bbut im etc'.
i reckon this modern love, but then that would be two 'slushy' singles and would give a very wrong impression of them.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

this modern love is great. why they released so here we are as a single i just don't understand.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

No little thoughts? What's the point then?

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Yep, its a magnificent record, and I say that even as arch indie sceptic.

I love So Here We Are though. Its the perfect shimmery indie ballad and the build up is fantastic.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

are u all downloading illegally?

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Not me, I've heard a copy that my 'friend' in the 'biz' was sent as a 'promo'.

Hope that's OK 'Dad'.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

They turned down a deal with EMI Records not Parlophone. People always confuse the two labels, same boss. I should know I was there at the time. I'm glad they are on an independent. Rising above all of the ridiculously over hyped major label signings of the last few months, Bloc Party are a shinning light. Everything else in the media's 2005 Hype list's is very poor in comparison.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

then i stand corrected.

xxx

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

its going through V2 - they did a joint venture with witchita. not that it matters

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm



they like Love Ends Disaster!!! how can it be bad.

the cover is very bunneyman, but then thats who travis based theirs on.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

i was hopeing they'd stick to the same format as the singles when it came to the album cover. ah well.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

i would've bought it no matter what this review said but now i feel fully justified about my determination to purchase the record. Im seeing them when they come to sunny Belgium in March. along with a capacity 250 people at a brilliant little venue. Viva la bloc.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Price Of Gas is the shittest song on the album, are you deaf?

Pioneers & Plans & Positive Tension are the highlights.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

no, i'm not deaf.

what don't you like about it?

pioneers is beautiful.

xxx

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

It's just not a good Bloc Party song.
The vocal melody is awful and the song is just a bit boring.
What do you like about it?

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

I disagree mate.
I think its possibly the most ambitious Bloc Party song I've heard to date.
It doesn't stick to any "angular", "post-punk", or "discordant" (insert adjective of choice) formula and quite simply suggests Bloc Party are the new Specials, the intelligent Happy Mondays, the clean-living Primal Scream and (thank fuck) the antidote to Kasabian.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

it's spooky and sexy and danceable, there's something compelling about it. i like the way it seems to be two songs slotted together in slices.

xxx

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Cannot wait to get my mitts on it.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Yep. Downloaded half the tracks. Sounds great. Really enjoyed them live in October. Will buy this when it comes out. Sorted.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

I think Pioneers could be the radio 1 killing single someone was talking about, it's pretty accesible, while still giving the right impression. Anyway, this album's excellent, apart from blue light which completely takes the wind out of it's sails after the first 4 tracks being so urgent...

As for leaving Little thoughts off, it really wouldn't fit, because (in crude terms) it's just too happy, Silent Alarm is upbeat but doesn't seem cheerful too often...

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

I'd love the crossover single to be Like Eating Glass, that's the most anthemic song I've heard since Doves' Pounding.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

it is fucking great, isn't it.

xxx

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Banquet's on it right? I need that song on a CD.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Yep, the single version with the heavier drums...

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

i love that song

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

aaah its been such a long wait.. so i did download the album, but once its released it will be making its way to these very hands. it's really a beautiful record, surely they will outlive the hype. lovelylovely!

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm


If they're lucky, and this album isn't pure shyte, I'll buy it like a good an honest boy. But before I do that, I'll need to give it a good and proper listen......*puts on the eye-patch*........ARRRRRGH!!!

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Sounds good cant wait to hear it expect other new cross bands to emerge this year,

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Turning down a major label deal isn't about integrity, it's common sense. Look at HIFH.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

'So Here We Are' forgettable? Is this some duff demo version you're listening to?

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Sounds like it's the version featured in the video - compared to the other singles I've heard so far, it's a little... well, not as good.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Hmm on first listen to the current single I agreed with those sentiments but on reflection I think So Here We Are is an amazing piece of music. And the good thing is there is even better stuff on the album.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

hands up who thinks this will get album of the year.
im think its fairly likely...although funeral by arcade fire finally comes out here next month (about bloody time) and thats the other top runner.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
"Turning down a major label deal isn't about integrity, it's common sense. Look at HIFH."-idlewildman

not just HIFH, but HR and all sorts of other bands that get signed to a major on a wave of hype . . . looks like bloc party made the decision that would give them most freedom and best shot at longevity

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

err, franz ferdinand. look how successful they are now

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Has anyone pointed out yet how much So Here We Are sounds like U2? Just wondering. That's not a diss, by the way.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

and obviously i wasn't the only one to think that some of the recent N*E-favoured 'hot' British acts had a touch of The Police about them...that was one of the first things i thought of when i heard Franz. Hmm....

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

cant wait to get my mits on this

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

wonder how long it will be before we hear a hot new band that doesnt really sound like anyone else at all

a life time if nme has anything to say about it i bet

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

er...tv on the radio?

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

seconded.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

i'm over my bloc party obsession after listening to this a few times. it's a good debut and it has a few great songs but i'm sure they'll go on to make better albums. some of the lyrics are pretty poor and it didn't really suck me in.

'compliments' is weak closer too if you ask me. it sounded a lot better on the peel session.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

once again, DiS follows rather than leads ..

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

well, what would you like us to do? tear it apart in a half-cocked attempt to be innovative? it's a great album. if we're not alone in saying it, that's testament to the quality of Silent Alarm.

xxx

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

would it have got such a good review if it hadn't been so absurdly praised by the NME?

when was the last time a DiS writer expressed an opinion that hadn't been ripped off from one of the major music magazines? there are plenty of good bands that aren't being covered by the mainstream press but DiS ignores them.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Hang on a minute.
DiS were talking about Bloc Party a good 9 months before the NME had got anywhere near them FFS!
If thats following rather than leading then I'd rather be a follower, wouldn't you?

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

i don't buy the nme, fella. i've bought it maybe once in about 6 months - this week's copy with bloc party on the front. [i swiftly came to the conclusion that i'm glad i haven't wasted my cash on it otherwise, because the amount they fucking go on about bloc party - this week, BLOC PARTY! next week, BLOC PARTY! - i'd probably be royally sick of them by now if i was a regular nme reader.]

i wrote the above review in december when i heard the album, and it was held back until closer to the release date. as dom says, many at DiS have been impressed with bloc party for a very long time. i'm just glad if the NME exposure they've now gotten has played a part in elevating them to the deserved success they're enjoying.

little i can say if you're truly convinced that we all study the nme slavishly, but that's your own problem really.

xxx

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

that's the most bonkers statement ever. there's hundreds of good bands covered by no music magazine (save maybe Wire or Loose Lips) that get covered by DiS. I know DiS isn't perfect, but they are independent from the NME. DiS has been giving Bloc Party much press ever since their demo as Union. And yes, I think it would have got such a good review. And to be fair Sir, you sound like a member of a band who hasn't got covered by DiS and you're bitter. I'm just off to laugh at you behind your back for a while.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

i'm not in a band, have never been in a band and have no desire to ever be in a band. My big problem with this site is that there is no mechanism for it to genuinely champion new bands. It's basically a collection of barely related reviews. It needs an equivalent of a magazine front cover. A few good reviews aren't enough for DiS to say they're genuinely pushing a new band - do you see what i'm getting at ?

incidentally, there's really no need for you or gen to be rude ...

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

But thats the whole point with DiS.
Unlike the NME, it doesn't state to be "pushing" certain bands on certain labels. There is no company policy that in order to write for DiS you should like (insert band names here)unlike the NME, which is why one writer's ecstasy could very wel be another's agony, which is what makes DiS stand apart as the writers are actually allowed to have and put forward their own opinions.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

You're right, the good thing about DiS is the freedom of expression it allows its writers. But the problem is that this is also expressed in its rather labyrinthine (sorry if I've spelt this wrong) structure. I can see the guys point- a front cover would make stuff easier to find- but it would become too didactic. He wants to have his cake and eat it basically (I'm not trying to be rude here)- DiS either has to 'push' a line or risk letting things go under the radar on occasion. The only reason why Bloc Party are plastered all over the site is that they're a) very active and b) bloody good.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Do you find it hard to navigate round DiS then?
I really like this site's structure - everything easily accessible.

Think the forum should be sorted out a bit though as when you get about 4 replies to a post the message board fails to indent and it gets hard to work out who's replying to who.

I like the current hompage as it sets it apart rags like the NME who push a line. They feature cool new bands, but in a more subtle way.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

surely that's self-defeating? people will only read reviews of bands they know and DiS achieves nowt. I'm not going to trail through thousands of reviews to find one positive review of dubious reliability and go and see a band off the back of it. The NME's editorial policy, at the very least, makes it coherent - however distasteful i find its choice of bands. I can't help but feel DiS needs to be more proactive rather than being an organic reflection of what the 16-23 age group is buying, which is what it seems to be.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

I'm not going to trail through thousands of reviews to find one positive review of dubious reliability and go and see a band off the back of it.

well i guess it depends on what you regard as dubious reliability. i think a lot of people find writers whose tastes have parallels with theirs - in theory that goes, i think, for any magazine/website - and DO check out bands on that basis. on here alone i've investigated bands based on mat hocking's reviews f'rinstance [e.g. since by man, ephel duath].

it seems like you're very cynical about the site as a whole. if that's the case, you're entitled to your opinion. i don't think every single person on here necessarily approaches things the same way.

incidentally, part of the proactivity comes from the user-interaction; messageboards, profiles, ratings etc. band profiles tell you what else fans of that band are listening to and rating, and the boards are there for a reason. so be proactive yourself. who do you rate? who should we be covering? shout about some bands you like. it's something you seem to feel strongly about, so use your voice and do something about it. otherwise it's a bit rich accusing us of being followers...

xxx

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

well, every individual chooses to listen to different thing so it's entirely unrealistic to expect any individual writer to deliver endless sucessful recomendations. If the site had some coherent policy on this then i could finally decide whether or not it's worth reading .....

Surely you can see my dilemma? It's not just about reliability. There are so many reviews on here that i simply don't have time to trawl through hundreds of reviews of stuff i've never heard of and am unlikely to be interested in just to find a solitary band that i might like. can you not appreciate that that's a problem? as one of the writers, you may be more aware of the other writers' musically tastes than i am ... i dunno if other readers have the same problem.

incidentally, the band recommendation thing on the user account is a bit of a waste of time, really.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

well i guess it depends on what you regard as dubious reliability. i think a lot of people find writers whose tastes have parallels with theirs - in theory that goes, i think, for any magazine/website - and DO check out bands on that basis

Yes, I would say that this is how things tend to work... on clicking articles about bands that I haven't heard of then I will be more inclined to check out the band if it is by Gareth just because he is someone that I've tended to agree with from his articles about bands that I did already know. Although since it doesn't actually say the writer on the front page normally it doesn't help so much with choosing articles, but I would have said that there is a small enough amount of stuff posted here that I can at least skim through almost everything that I can't tell that I won't be interested in.