Drowned in Sound

Search



silent alarm remixed bloc party

Bloc Party: Silent Alarm: Remixed

no votes
?
by Mike Diver
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 12/09/2005
  • Label: Wichita
From the pre-listen outset, the concept is fairly flawed: the word ‘remix’, forever synonymous with the field of dance music, is an unnecessary suffix to many a Bloc Party song, such is the toe-tapping immediacy of much of the original Silent Alarm. This project – basically a compiling of re-worked b-sides and a handful of rarities – smacks entirely of cash in, quick. Now, I’m not one to knock that – bands should absolutely exploit their profiles while they’re in such a position, because any lay person knows fame is both fickle and fleeting – but Silent Alarm: Remixed just seems like the wrong way to maintain a level of exposure between albums proper.

Why? Because laziness is never to be celebrated, however much The Idler would argue otherwise. Had Bloc Party’s upcoming UK tour not sold out long ago, this record would undoubtedly serve as a timely catalyst; with sales assured, though, one wonders what the thinking behind this is, exactly. Completists will have the tracks, while newcomers – your five records a year types – are unlikely to be moved into purchasing action by the names Four Tet, M83 and Pretty Girls Make Graves’ Jason Clark. But, anyway, the record…

…Isn’t so terrible, really: skim the superfluous and far-too-slight mixes from the surface and there are gems to be found (unless you’ve got them at home already). The aforementioned trio do wondrous things to ‘So Here We Are’, ‘The Pioneers’ and ‘Positive Tension’ respectively; particularly of note is M83’s show-stealing mix, massively symphonic yet skin-pricklingly affecting simultaneously. Clark’s sinister electro-spook stylings are Xeroxed nicely by Ladytron, whose gently pulsing ‘Like Eating Glass’ opens proceedings nicely enough.

Whitey’s take on ‘Helicopter’ provides a little unintentional humour, the wolf-tongued howls absolutely out of place alongside such steely and crisp guitars. Yet the disparate nature of …Remixed’s contributors denies it the coherency of the original: Erol Alkan and Paul Epworth’s Phones come unstuck through simply not adding anything to the originals; if the truth be told they butcher ‘She’s Hearing Voices’ and ‘Banquet’ into by-numbers thud-thud affairs devoid of discernible character. Starrier names take pot shots to indifferent effect: Nick Zinner, Mogwai, Death From Abover 1979… the listener is left unmoved.

That said, the positive does exceed the negative, just; problem is, who’s going to care enough – themselves too lazy to risk a tenner on a stopgap – to find out? Silent Alarm: Remixed, to be frank, isn't wholly necessary. As a result, seek this out in bargain bins rather than premium-priced new release racks.

  • Bloc Party 5 / 10

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

Waste of space this. File under the section marked "Cash In" and leave there for all eternity...

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

this is mega patchy and yes, a bit of cynical release.

the white one is complete crap and just takes away everything interesting about the original track. shame because whitey is great.

DFA1979 one is meh, you wouldn't expect them to make the bass sound LESS interesting.

I like the four tet one though.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

i really liked the mogwai one, thought it was one of the best. but i think most of the decent ones on this are available on cheap singles or something. won't buy.

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

You really don't like the Whitey one? Its a fantastic indie disco tune. I prefer it to the original.

I think many of them are weak efforts though. Some songs just don't do well with remixing.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

i think this album is pretty fucking good, i like the way some of the original tracks that were a bit 'weak' have been improved, and how the great tracks off the original have been approached from a different angle

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

I'll probably nab the Four Tet, M83 and Mogwai ones off iTunes (or for free if I can, 'cause I'm a crazed, law-breaking fool). I've already got the 'Banquet', 'Modern Love' and DFA1979 ones, and apart from the DFA cover it's pretty "meh."

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

I've not heard the full album. The Remixes I've heard I thought were pretty good. Lovin The sheriff whitey remix of helicopter, even better than the original in my opinion. And is there a BP song where the drumming isn't mint?

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

The drumming is pure chunky munky.

Everything else doesn't even match up to those lolly ices you get from Farm Foods that cost 50p for like, 20 of them and the only great thing about them is that at least the stick had the decency to splinter you so you'd remember not to buy them again.

Bloc Party are pants.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

I thought it was quite good. Look for the Engineers effort of Blue Light as well, that's better than the original.

Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

I dont like the way this mr reviewer assumes there is only two types of fan 'the completist' and the 'newcomer' surely there are people that might buy a bloc album that aren't completists? all this cash in talk is very cynical, maybe bloc just wanted to release something nice for those who might like it

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

its a blatant cash in
im surprised they havent re-released the original album with a 'free' DVD yet or one with extra tracks

*rolls eyes*

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

its a blatant cash in
im surprised they havent re-released the original album with a 'free' DVD yet or one with extra tracks

*rolls eyes*

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

The original album came with a DVD, so unless they made it a double dvd boxset or something...

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

Don't give them any idea...

Re: Bloc Party - Silent Alarm: Remixed

haha, they are actually re-releasing the album with an extra dvd :S