Drowned in Sound

Search



New Order Singles

New Order: Singles

no votes
?
by Dom Gourlay
After the tragic suicide of Ian Curtis, surely no one - least of all the band themselves - could have expected that 25 years down the line the surviving three members of Joy Division would still be going strong and churning out their 30th hit single as New Order in that time.

Indeed, whilst the eerie poignant uncertainty of 'Ceremony' - the last thing Joy Division wrote together just before Curtis' death - suggested the band would attempt to continue where they'd left off, what followed next was an education in itself, proving that boys brought up on coaldust and guitars could actually dance, whilst reaffirming the fact that technological experiments in music need not necessarily be tuneless and unlistenable.

It would be easy to criticise New Order, as many have, for a number of reasons, most notably the so-called lack of respect shown to their departed frontman by, lo-and-behold, "selling out" a.k.a. achieving commercial success, or their apparent lack of charisma - try telling that to the tabloid hacks who spent years salivating over the Caroline Ahern-Peter Hook soap opera - and yet throughout the quarter of a century, they still remain effortlessly cool and annoyingly aloof, which would suggest they have and still are obviously doing something right.

Singles, spread chronologically across two CDs, follows on where 2002's Retro boxset left off, in that every nook and cranny, false start and unintentionally faded middle eight (see the original single mix of 'Temptation') is here in all its glory.

Innovators rather than followers, it's easy to see why New Order have been held in high esteem for so long, as 1983's 'Blue Monday' - possibly the first record ever to successfully mix the sound of guitars and the discotheque as well as being the biggest selling 12 inch single of its time - and 'Confusion', which predated this nation's fascination with hip-hop by half a decade at least, are both still as fresh and invigorating as they were way back then.

Towards the end of the eighties, New Order were fast becoming one of the country's best pop acts in their own right, and the likes of 'True Faith' and 'Bizarre Love Triangle' mixed the cement and paved the way for young upstarts such as Hard-Fi and Franz Ferdinand today.

The second CD sees the band embrace acid house ('Fine Time'), lick its lips with Manchester's second wave - the baggy explosion ('Run 2') and try - and ultimately fail - to teach footballers how to rap ('World In Motion')... though it's still make the most credible, non-laddish football song ever. If CD2 is a game of two halves, the finale is a bit of an anti-climax and probably the reason why this record doesn't quite achieve the ultimate accolade of 5 stars, but the pragmatic tones of 'Krafty' suggest that even now, New Order still have enough creativity left in them to carry on for a while longer yet, and for a band whose core members are probably older than most DiS readers' parents, that is a commendable achievement in itself.

As a memento of what happens when two extremely diverse factions (punk rock and disco) collide under the same roof, Singles is an absolute must. Where greatest hits compilations are concerned, I guarantee you won't find a better one than Singles this year or even this decade.

  • New Order 9 / 10

New Order - Singles

as much as i love them, do we need YET ANOTHER New Order singles compilation?

Re: New Order - Singles

To be honest, I'm more worried that this has spelled death for their other new record, which I think was meant to be about early next year.

Re: New Order - Singles

Because this is the only one to contain all their singles to date, some of which were never on any album (especially the early ones).

Of the previously released compilations, Substance only covers the first dozen or so, and the Best Of from 1994, and International (i think!) only contain fairly random selections.

Why they hadn't bothered to do this before, i'm not sure.

New Order - Singles

I always thought the cure did the new order sound better than new order.

I like blue monday and few other singles the rest is not that interesting to me, and generally incomparable to Joy Division.

Re: New Order - Singles

Yeah, like you can really compare Killing an Arab or Lovecats with Temptation or Bizarre Love Triangle

New Order - Singles

Watched New Order on telly at Glastonbury- thought they looked a bit shambolic and past it. Saw them in the flesh at T in the Park- fucking amazing.

New Order - Singles

'love, love will tear us apart, CMON, CMON YEAH"

Awful.

Re: New Order - Singles

Yes, that is sacrilege. However Sumner is still a fantastic guitarist.

New Order - Singles

their cover of love will tear us apart is somewhat horrific. you'd think they of all people wouldnt want to desecrate it. i've heard that nada surf did it better.

New Order - Singles

there are no guitars on Blue Monday. Not one of the mixes. Though they did use guitars when they played it live in 2002.

Ian's death didn't really affect them. They would've sounded just like New Order, though with a sulkier singer. Ian loved the electro stuff, and used to play Kraftwerk before he went on stage.

Re: New Order - Singles

I've always wondered what they would have sounded like if Ian Curtis was still alive.
The electronic U2 perhaps?
Baffling...

Re: New Order - Singles

Jesus the cynicism is baffling. They wrote the music for all of Joy Division's songs. They WERE Joy Division. They obviously enjoy playing them, so I'd hardly say its sacrilegious for them to play Love Will Tear Us Apart. Its hardly Hundred Reasons singing How Soon is Now?. And whats wrong with Bernard Sumner shouting "come on!" during it? When LWTUA plays at an indie club, do all of you sit in the corner and look like you're deeply contemplating the admittedly melacholic lyrics? No. You jump around and have a good time. So why cant Bernard Sumner fucking well do that while he's singing it?

And for readers to put themselves in the bandmember's shoes and say that they didnt care when Ian Curtis died is a remarkably idiotic and unfounded assertion. Gah!

Re: New Order - Singles

Kill me now.

Re: New Order - Singles

Go'an yourself bigmanwithagun, very euruditely put.

Seeing Barney have a good time is a rare event and should be celebrated.

Re: New Order - Singles

I often feel that those who slag New Order off for playing Division songs haven't actually been in a crowd while they're doing it. I saw New Order at T this summer, and the feeling was amazing, it was one of the best gig experiences I've ever had..