Drowned in Sound

Search



JohnnyCashHurt

Johnny Cash: Hurt

no votes
?
by Chris Nettleton
I wish all cover versions were this interesting and this genuine... forming a bridge between musical styles that to all intents and purposes are alien to each other ... in this case a legendary icon from one world of music covering a song written by an icon from another world.

Johnny Cash, his voice both rich with authority and fragile with old age, injects a kind of intimate dignity to Nine Inch Nails's pathos ridden postscript to 'The Downward Spiral' album, but where Trent Reznor was whispering a reflective eulogy on self destruction, Cash is being ravaged by the gradual physical disintegration that will probably get every one of us in the end. As I'd kind of expect with Rick Rubin producing, it sounds very intimate and simple, just an acoustic guitar and gentle piano chords backing that voice... emotional, naked and unadorned, like the legendary 'Man In Black' is in there with you, singing to you in your room. I didn't miss the erratic electronic textures and effects that were prominent on the original, and though it's occasionally evident that this is a singer wandering in territory far away from his musical origins, it's almost impossible not to be won over by the serene beauty of this record.

..Worth mentioning that the second track (It was so much cooler when you could call them B-sides!) contains another foray into industrial classics, namely a cover of Dépeche Mode's anthem, 'Personal Jesus', which is styled into a dark acoustic blues rock stomp that suits it well,and also worth highly recommending the album these tracks are taken from - 'American IV: The Man Comes Around', released last year on American Recordings

Track Listing

  1. 'Hurt'(album version)
  2. 'Personal Jesus'(album version)
  3. 'Wichita Lineman'(vinyl version)
  4. 'Hurt' (video)
  • Johnny Cash 9 / 10

Johnny Cash - Hurt

Nicely put, Nettles. I used to take the piss out of my dad's Johnny Cash tapes until I heard him doing Soundgarden's Rusty Cage. I really hope this song leads to some sort of popularity surge for the man.

Re: Johnny Cash - Hurt

whoop... the only problem i have with this review is that it didn't get 5/5.. but hey.

Re: Johnny Cash - Hurt

I'm getting a bit harsh as to when I give out my 5/5s. I wouldn't give a brilliant record 5/5, but probably 4.5 (I might change this one to 4.5, 'cause it was probably a bit harsh to give just a four). 5/5 is saved for records that are going to be amongst my fave of all time. Dunno if this is too harsh, but I'm swinging the other way after being someone who gave every other review top points. On the album, my favourite track is his cover of 'Bridge Over Troubled Water', which truly blows the mind. The timing and meter (and power) of that song suit his voice better than 'Hurt' or 'Personal Jesus', in my humble opinion.

With respects to 'Hurt', I shed my big tears when the original came out. This was the bit on 'Downward Spiral' that tied the album together, and cut through to the bone, much like 'Something I Will Never Have' On 'Pretty Hate Machine'. Both songs made me bawl at the time, and the latter still tingles the same nerve ten years later.


Johnny Cash - Hurt

I seriously broke down in big tears the first time I heard him do Hurt. Reminded me of a long lost friend. Too painful, too close to the bone.

Re: Johnny Cash - Hurt

I choked up on seeing the video for Hurt. Such powerful imagery! It helps that the directing, editing, and overall concept is absolutely perfect... I am not a Johnny Cash fan; but I think that the video for 'Hurt' makes a most-fitting eulogy for The Man In Black. I think I watched the video about 10 times back-to-back, which is definitely a record for me, and doubly surprising because I don't like C&W (but this isn't C&W now, is it?).