Drowned in Sound

Search



oasis lyla cover

Oasis: Lyla

no votes
?
by Alex Wisgard
  • Type: Single
  • Release date: 16/05/2005
  • Label: Big Brother
Liam: You've got to progress, but it doesn't mean to say you've got to go forward.
Noel: Eh?
Liam: You can progress sideways. Or backwards. I'm right. Tell me I'm not.
Noel: Progression is going forwards. Going backwards is regression. Going sideways is just gression.

So the brothers Gallagher wittily quipped in a 1994 press conference; but who knew they’d stick so rigidly to what they said. 10 years after the fantastic ‘...Morning Glory’ album, rather than sticking out a re-release, Oasis have decided to pull their socks up and release a new album. As the first single from forthcoming studio album No. 6 ‘Don’t Believe The Truth’, ’Lyla’ is also their first since the 90’s to have the old Oasis logo plastered on it’s cover, suggesting that it’s the band’s biggest return to the sound of their golden age. Gallagher the elder has talked it up as “The Who...the poppiest thing we’ve done since 'Roll With It'...specifically designed for pogoing”, but as with any N. Gallagher hyperbole (anyone remember Proud Mary?), it’s also a major, though not entirely unexpected, disappointment.

‘Lyla’ is no ‘Roll With It’ - hell, it’s no ‘Hindu Times’, but whereas that single had swagger and purpose, this one just plods; “I’ve waited for a thousand years for you to come and blow me out my mind,” Liam sings in his trademark sneer, just before the predictably ‘anthemic’ chorus begins. With Noel cribbing chords from both his own ‘Hindu Times’ and his beloved Stone Roses‘I Am The Resurrection’, as well as penning his usual cliché-laden lyrics (“The star’s about to fall...heaven help me, catch me if I fall,” indeed), ‘Lyla’ sounds like an Oasis parody, or worse, an Oasis tribute band trying to write their own song. It’s their least interesting single since ‘Who Feels Love’, and if this is the most immediate thing on the album, they may have been better off reissuing ‘...Morning Glory’ after all. Now what was it you were saying about progress, Liam?

  • Oasis 4 / 10

Oasis - Lyla

What an absolute humongous pile of rhinosarus turd this song is.

And they look like such dickheads in the video.
Probably, beacuse, they, like are.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

At least they don't look like University Challenge students with angular haircuts, which makes a change these days. Loving Liam's Pillinger-esque sideys too.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

hmmmmm....... yes.... didn't you just nick that quote from your beloved Liam from the NME re: bloc Party?
eh?
eh?
tsk.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

The University Challenge bit was, yeah. Still a valid point though. Why do most new bands these days look like pseudo-dorks? Jarvis Cocker's innate geekiness was genuine, most of these new bands are just faking it.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

since when has anyone as trendy looking as bloc party been on university challenge?

Re: Oasis - Lyla

pah. i'm gonna start a band called University Challenge, and they're gonna be massive style icons.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

but Bloc Party DO look like University Challenege students.
whereas Oasis look like... turds.

I do enjoy a good Oasis interview though. I'd take out an NME subscription if they did them every week.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

I actually feel a bit sorry for Bloc Party now. I quite like some of their music but they should never have dissed Oasis in print. Once you provoke the wrath of Noel Gallagher you're in big trouble. Look what happened to Starsailor.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

To be fair, starsailer are/were utter shit.

Oasis should be dissed in print EVERY DAY. How the hell can Oasis critisise anyones image? They looked like tossers in the 90's, and still do now. Nice glasses. Cunt.

The Bloc Party album was great, at least Bloc Party have some ideas, the last idea Liam and Noel proably had was "oooh... I want a parka jacket."

Re: Oasis - Lyla

Starsailor had a couple of nice tunes. I liked Good Souls. The singer's voice become very grating after a while though. And he was a cock.

Oasis can criticise whoever they like, just as Bloc Party can. The difference is, when Bloc Party do it they're just pissing in the wind. No one cares. When Oasis do it NME sales go through the roof and humourless twats have a hissy fit. Cashback!

As for the Bloc Party album, it was alright in a sub-Franz Ferdinand, neo post-punk kind of way. As debut albums go, it was hardly in the Psychocandy, Stone Roses, Definitely Maybe league.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

Thats true actually. The NME sold out in two days in the whole town.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

I listened to the Starsailor album for the first time in years last week and was pleasently surprised. Its not great or groundbreaking, but I was kind of expecting it to sound shit. And it didn't.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

I kinda like it.

Oasis - Lyla

One of their worst ever singles, simple as.

Oasis - Lyla

It's poor. Change the drumbeat. Stop that whining guitar rhythm in the background. Just do...*something*, to make me go 'Oh...well its better than the last three albums'.

You've failed again lads.

Oasis - Lyla

I love it. Quality rock'n'roll pop tune. Pounding drums, positive lyrics, joyous singalong chorus. Beats shite like the new Foo Fighters single into a cocked-hat. Sure-fire Number 1, as long as that bastard frog doesn't get in the way.

Oasis - Lyla

this track is so tedious. it sounds like a lame attempt at being like the "cool" band of today. it's such a far cry from their mid 90s 'classics'.
Liam G, after you're interview in NME, one thing is clear, you have nothing to say, and you're saying it too loud, so, Bollocks.


Re: Oasis - Lyla

If Oasis were trying to be the 'cool' band of today surely they'd be making 80s synth-pop a la Killers/Bravery or post-punk a la Franz/Bloc Party. This single is about as uncool as you could get, and all the better for it. And Liam's interview in NME was funny as fuck.

Oasis - Lyla

shiticus maximus

Oasis - Lyla

This is a great song. If you disagree, YOU ARE WRONG.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

Good lad.

Oasis - Lyla

It's just staggeringly bad! When I heard it for the first time I couldn't quite believe it. It's lyrically appaling, even for oasis, and doesn't even contain one single, solitary hook. Whatever Noel says, not even he can think this will cut the mustard in 2005.

In fact, surely the bell now tolls for oasis? They should have split when half the band left in 1999, but if this is the best they can do for a comeback single after three years, isn't it time to call it a day? They made their solitary great record more than ten years ago, and since at least 1997 they've just been spoiling its memory.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

They should have split when half the band left in 1999, but if this is the best they can do for a comeback single after three years, isn't it time to call it a day? They made their solitary great record more than ten years ago, and since at least 1997 they've just been spoiling its memory.

Oasis - Lyla

i'll drink to that seibu

Oasis - Lyla

Anyone noticed the one user repeatedly sticking up for Oasis in this review, trying to make it look levelled out, between 'i like the song' and 'i don't like the song' comments?
as it happens, it's just a boring song. then again, i didn't even like early oasis, so i'm not likely to like this

Oasis - Lyla

This song is fucking awful. Lazy same old crap from Oasis.
Go away and write something we've not heard before. And shave those sideys off while you're at it Gallagher Jnr.

Oasis - Lyla

granted, oasis are never going to revolutionise the state of music, but i cannot understand why there is this passionate hatred of them...'lyla' is rock n roll, its not an existential study of human life, it won' t help solve world debt, it isn't going to challenge the people who make up genre titles, but its got a pulse and a heart and its oasis making a return to their morning glory era..no bad thing!!! they gave us definitely maybe, and all we can seem to do is criticise and snipe. shame! they're still the dog's bollocks. end of story.

Oasis - Lyla

Seeing men well into their 30's do My Generation was a bit err... But Noel calling Woss a cockney cunt was funny.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

Good thing you have't seen The Who do it, they're 60

Oasis - Lyla

I guess I'll just continue to listen to Wonderwall for another decade....

Re: Oasis - Lyla

R u kidden me ,i know wonderwall is a good song but there is alot better songs by them such as supersonic, my generation, don't look back in anger and the list goes on. So you should listen to the real tunes cause Lyla is amazing .If u get this message please reply saying Wonderwalls not your favourite song or u r not right in the head

Re: Oasis - Lyla

Oasis wrote My Generation, eh? that's news to me. better tell Pete Townshend and the rest of The Who...

Re: Oasis - Lyla

Lyla is proof they've totally run out of inspiration and should hang up the guitars and tambourine for good.

The verse especially is a total rip-off - it starts off being Street Fighting Man and then finishes as Masterplan (at least that's their own song).

Shame really - Definitely Maybe was (and still is) a mighty album.

Maybe you can't write good rock songs anymore once you've got rich and complacent. They're not the only band it's happened to.

Oasis - Lyla

liams voice+a drone+that drum beat=SO inadvisable.
there is no feeling of propulsion AT ALL.

Oasis - Lyla

I quite like it actually. Not going to change the world, but what do you expect? Sounds quite Doves-y, and i prefer it to any of the singles from Heathen Chemistry for a start.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

Sounds Doves-y? TAKE THAT BACK, BITCH.

Oasis - Lyla

Yes, but Heathen Chemistry sucked.

Its like saying crap tastes better than shit.

Oasis - Lyla

I'm with the negatives. I will always love them, however old and farty they get, but fuck's sake, get some dynamism in your tracks and ditch the chunka-chunka. Look at "Acquiesce" and "Headshrinker" and think, how do we write some kickass r n roll again? This is Ok on the album, but the "strongest song on it" (Q review)? Oh dear bollocks. He is still The Rock Voice of our times tho whatever shite he sings.

Oasis - Lyla

Yawn

I think that sums it up

Re: Oasis - Lyla

cool oasis coin on ebay.

Oasis - Lyla

i really wanted to like this song as oasis were an integeral part of my childhood etc.. but its pretty impossible to.

how many tedious britpop chord sequences are there left? for ducks sake

Oasis - Lyla

Don't worry peeps, having heard the album I can confirm Lyla is the worst song on it. It is a fantastic album with no tracks I'll be skipping (even this one has it's charm in places!) It is always amusing to see people write a band off after one song. Give the album a chance - you will be very pleasantly surprised.

Re: Oasis - Lyla

I don't think, by this point, it's even possible to write Oasis off with one song. Write them off again with one more song, perhaps. I've never liked Oasis anyway and Lyla was far from about to change my mind or make me want to give them 'a chance'.

Oasis - Lyla

I think this song is MAJIK cause considering they havent had a song out 4 ages ,its pritty good their new album don't believe the truth will be the start of a new Oasis. I dont know why some of you lot hate the son because itisso them .I am going t their tour at Glasgow and whenthey sing lyla i bet you no-one will boo tem everyone will be going crazy