Drowned in Sound

Search



Snow Patrol Eyes Open

Snow Patrol: Eyes Open

no votes
?
by Dom Gourlay
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 01/05/2006
  • Label: Fiction

Who'd have thought that when Songs For Polar Bears came out all those years ago - an understated gem in the-then burgeoning Glasgow underground scene - its creators' fourth opus almost a decade later would be one of the most eagerly anticipated albums of 2006 by both the record buying public and tabloid media whores alike?

If the initial student dormitory project of Gary Lightbody and Mark McClelland called Snow Patrol wasn't meant to go stellar then its incumbents have failed. But of course - in Lightbody's mind at least - we all know that wasn't the case. Sadly, McClelland is no longer part of the band to see it through into the big arenas. Ousted from the band last year, I suppose all good-on-the-surface relationships have to come to an end some time. Maybe McClelland's mind was still set in indie bedsitland while his co-conspirator had visions of grandeur, sipping champers with Bono and Chris Martin. Whatever the reasons behind the fall-out, it's probably fair to say that if relationships didn't break up then there wouldn't be much else for Lightbody and co. to write about, as the majority of Eyes Open seems to go to great lengths about splitting up and getting back together and...well, you know.

Take 'Make This Go On Forever' for example, a ballad so shrouded in sentimentality it could set up its own lonely hearts column in the Telegraph. Lightbody seemingly writes an open letter to his (soon to be) ex-missus with lines like "And we should spend some time apart, for both our sakes" and ten thousand housewives up and down the country will no doubt put down the latest Mills & Boon paperback and shed a tear or two with him. 'Starfighter Pilot' this ain't then, but don't let that put you off. No really, Eyes Open isn't a bad record.

If anything, Snow Patrol have taken the blueprint from their multi-platinum selling Final Straw record that one step further. An organic process perhaps, or maybe a calculated move, as their detractors upon hearing lead single 'You're All I Have' will have been quick to point out. The thing is though, even back in the day when they were sharing record labels and plimsoles with members Belle And Sebastian, they never professed to being anything more than competent songwriters. Certainly not genre redefining rule breakers at any rate, so why anyone would expect them to go that way now is beyond belief, to be honest.

It's perhaps the departure of McClelland that has caused the most dramatic change in the shape and feel of the record, not least by way of the fact Lightbody effectively recruited two new members to replace him. Musically, there is a more polished feel to Eyes Open than on any of their previous long players, which suggests that the royalty cheques from Final Straw were put to better use than enjoying a maximum rock'n'roll lifestyle. Certainly, employing Jacknife Lee to produce the record may have been a masterstroke, as despite the high number of big ballads on this record, the addition of several twiddly bits and drum loops in many of the right places helps reduce the schmaltz level by at least 50 percent.

The likes of 'Hands Open' and 'It's Beginning To Get To Me' are the most obvious follow-up singles, both of which seem to want to rock out and sulk in self pity in equal measures, while the duet with Martha Wainwright, 'Set The Fire To The Third Bar', is reminiscent of Magnet and Gemma Hayes' Dylan cover 'Lay Lady Lay' in outlook, owing to Wainwright's dulcet tones, although lines like "The laughter penetrates my silence as drunken men find flaws in science" create bleary visions of Shane'n'Kirsty too.

Overall, Eyes Open is the album that Snow Patrol were always going to make in the wake of their unexpected success. To sum them up in one word, "reliable" would be the most appropriate. Now has anyone seen the keys to my gaffer's Mondeo..?

  • Snow Patrol 6 / 10

An eight for me at least, fantastic record.


It's a simply beautiful album.


I haven't heard it but thought the single sounded like Del Amitri

...... which isn't a good thing. I like SP, went to Reindeer Section gigs and thought they were immense etc. You make a point of them not claiming to be the next great songwriters or something like that but from what I have heard the new stuff is a clear decline in standard. Only my opinion but i think they can do a lot better.


The new single

Is probably the worst on the album.


true

but let that not be a total disclaimer to the poor worth of the album


I love the new single

its so happy. its currently in my itunes playlist of uplifting songs along with Wake Up by the Arcade Fire and Pounding by Doves.


I'm baffled

how can the main sounce of negativity be placed on 'let this go on forever'?! It was by far the stand out track for me.

I would have ignored this album had it not been for that song and having given it a few listens I think the whole thing is rather fantastic.

Having been a fan of the band since the Polar bear starfighter I'm still a little dissapointed in how the band spanned out but fair play to them. They're still making good records so I don't see much room for complaint.


ok give me your opinion on

how these songs compare to something like I'll Be There When You Wake by Reindeer Section which i think Gary wrote. It's too easy to trash a band when they get up there, but i'm honestly not just having a go. Compared to previous efforts the music is too cheesey and glossy (so i take issue with the big up to the production mentioned in this review) and perhaps that takes some feeling of sencerity away from his voice making me question the lyrics too. Plus the single sounds like Del Amitri!!!!! I'm now guessing i'm the only one to pick up on this.


middle of the road

coffee table rubbish.

would rather have my ears filled with monkey gizz than listen to it.


anyone else

hear the rumour that McClelland was ousted when he started questioning the terms of their management deal?


i don't know

everyone is being very tight lipped about it all. i'm sure we've not heard the last of Marko though.


completely agree with you.
I do not rate this review.


Chasing Cars

...is my favourite on the album, reminds me of Lowgold in their "beauty dies young" hayday.

Personally I think the album sounds more complete than the last couple, i don't find myself skipping any tracks on this one!


didn't like polar bears

when i bought it a few years back (starfighter pilot being an obvious exception, the rest of it was boring), and i like the current single and run and the chocolate song. they do exactly what it says on the tin, and good on them for getting big and getting (at least some) money from doing what they enjoy.

i remember one of aerogramme in an interview ages ago saying something like; 'we could write anthems like idlewild and get rich, but we don't want to'. that annoyed me, why stay in a boring indie rut? (bad example: i hate idlewild post 100windows) life's for fun, don't ruin it out of fear. gary lightbody obviously had enough of being indie and couldn't hold onto his anthem writing talent any longer. good i say.. run's ace.


FLIPMODE!

I really enjoyed Songs For Polar bears, but couldn't fucking stand half of Final Straw. Thankfully, someone else bought it for me so I didn't feel like I'd wasted money on it.

I'm liking the single, though, has more testicles than the last few singles they've released.


flipmode

is the greatest


Snow patrol getting worse

I'm afraid they'll never beat 'Starfighter Pilot' or 'An olive grove facing the sea', though only heard the single and 'chasing cars'


the duet

with Martha Wainwright is good. check that out and stick it on repeat for a few listens.


I have

Final Straw and Polar Bears. Final Straw was amazing the first few listens, but it really irritates me now. Polar Bears isn't great either, bar a few tracks. Certainly no better than Final Straw, despite what some people say.

I heard a snippet of the new album in hmv: not impressed at all, although it was only one song


what about when its all over we still have to clear up?

you got polar bears and final straw but not when its all over... Its my fave album by them, give it a listen its not too poppy like the newer stuff but aint got any duff songs! great album


WIAOWSHTCU

It is actually a fantastic album, along with Songs For Polarbears. I cannot believe Lightbody fired McLelland because he wanted to go U2, the next massive stadium band. If they had gone back, made an underground indie album and gone back to their roots, they would have gained our respect and we would have fallen in love with them again. Instead, this album will be listened to and loved by mums and people having baths.

So, in the unlikely event of McLelland rejoining the band and them going back to playing the Glasgow School of Art, I doubt I will ever listen to anything they made after 2002.