How to start a review when all that’s rattling within your brain is its conclusion, the final, perfectly summarising parting statement? Muse have made the finest album of their career to date, perhaps the most wonderfully rewarding long-player they’ll ever pen, an album that is as ambitious as it is combustive, as bamboozlingly bombastic as it is gracefully seductive.
How about at the start itself…
Black Holes And Revelations unpredictably unveils itself slowly and cautiously – that single, the sound of Beck being mercilessly ravaged by Trent Reznor, has seen expectations rise to a level unprecedented, so it’s slightly surprising that Messrs Bellamy, Howard and Wolstenholme pitch their comparatively poorest cuts into the affray first. Opener ‘Take A Bow’ ripples and bubbles, a Grandaddy-esque electronic pulse beating like a pacemaker fuelled by fiery sunspots, but Bellamy’s lyrics – quite obviously political, as has already been widely reported – are one-dimensional to the point of Blunt-like banality.
A screech of tyres on sticky sunburnt tarmac come four-and-a-half minutes and the repetitive thud-thud-thud of ‘Starlight’ begins: an entirely bland power ballad in the hands of any other rock band, Muse skilfully twist undeserved drama from an essentially mundane composition, yet never truly engage the listener. Their cause isn’t helped by a clunky chorus, either, seemingly in position only to offer the illusion of depth where, in fact, every other lick and lyric suggests otherwise. It’s a love song, simple as, and a far from inspiring one. Next.
Black Holes... is a dizzying rollercoaster, a stand-up-too-fast headrush,
a beguiling beast of beauty and horror.
-----
But what a next: this, track three of eleven, is where Black Holes And Revelations earns itself that grand congratulatory opening paragraph. ‘Supermassive Black Hole’ has a ridiculous title, Matt Bellamy spends its three-and-a-half minute duration sounding as if he’s lubing his larynx up for frenzied tonsil tennis, and its satisfyingly sleazy musical framework is about as expected as said frontman asking, breathlessly, “Ooh baby, can you hear me moan?”
Ice cream in soda, snails in porridge, Matt Bellamy playing kinky sex kitten: some things in this world were never meant to be bedfellows, but each and every time wonderful results are borne of their stars’ alignment.
From here on in Black Holes And Revelations is a dizzying rollercoaster, a stand-up-too-fast headrush, a beguiling beast of beauty and horror. ‘Map Of The Problematique’ initially sounds like a violation of late-Eighties Depeche Mode, but upon repeat inspections it reveals itself to be quite the musical onion: peel the layers away and you’re likely to cry foul at its plagiarism, but consume whole and the sensation is striking. At the song’s core are Dominic Howard’s incessant drum beats, each strike of stick on skin booming like a meteorite impacting upon the Moon’s surface. ‘Assassin’ is better still, its opening riff cheekily robbing, unashamedly so, from the title music of Knight Rider. Probably the fastest three minutes in the album’s forty-five, the song serves as a stylistic bridge spanning the slightly over-the-top histrionics of ‘Invincible’ and one of the album’s most talked-about offerings, the swaggering ‘Exo-Politics’.
Bellamy is on record as saying that ‘Exo-Politics’ is conceptually concerned with conspiracy theories, with questions the layperson should be directing the way of governments with all switches seemingly stuck on self-destruct, but the song doesn’t get bogged down in intellectualisms: it, like so many of these songs, is primarily a rock song, and a fantastically fun one, too. For all the prog labels that Muse find themselves subjected to come each album release, there’s little on Black Holes And Revelations that even the most thick-skulled Neanderthal couldn’t get whiplash from – the head-banging possibilities are plentiful.
The album’s rear end is characterised by splashes of Morricone-coloured embellishment, each tiny facet of sound comprising an essential piece of this puzzling album – on paper, intelligence shouldn’t stand hand-in-hand with reckless excess quite so magisterially, so majestically. Come the record’s sustained climax, the scintillating ‘Knights Of Cydonia’ – surf rock re-imagined for extreme sports fanatics riding the shifting dunes of Mars – all the listener can do is allow themselves to be swept away in the rush. “How can we win, when fools can be kings?” asks Bellamy, a wall of noise just waiting to be unleashed all around him; again, the lyrics are wrapped up in see-through political analogies, but every time Muse’s singer delivers a slightly duff line, you can rest assured that a mighty riff will obliterate the memory of it in all of a few seconds. “You and I must fight to survive…”, and riff. A gigantic, rollicking, bucking, violent riff, battling and winning like a humpback hooked by a six-foot Kingfisher starter rod.
Black Holes... is likely to be the band’s OK Computer – the record
that everything they produce subsequently is immediately unfairly rated against, ‘til time’s own sands sit still.
-----
The urge to go around again is instantaneous, and even though Black Holes And Revelations begins with a whimper, its steady, ever-building roar is a wonder to behold. The work of three individuals arriving at the peak of their powers, it’s likely to be the band’s OK Computer, their Music For The Jilted Generation, their Dark Side Of The Moon – the record that everything they produce subsequently is immediately unfairly rated against, ‘til time’s own sands sit still.
Should they never make another album, Muse can retire safe in the knowledge that pretentious rulebook re-writing and perfunctory by-numbers rocking have never mixed so alluringly.
I love you
Great review.
i like the pullquotes
see also: grandaddy interview
no WAY
i'm going!!!
yeah
please use those as standard - it's a very good idea.
pullwuotes only work
when the writing's up to a standard where you actually WANT to pull a quote from it
what a brilliant review
It almost makes me want to buy this album. They’ve had 3 chances. They aint getting a forth.
Great review.
Spot on!
give me a break
every review of this album seems to be either obnoxiously negative or ridiculously positive. but 'Black Holes...' is just an expected development for Muse... it's like a summery, poppy Absolution. it's as good as the last two records, it's great, but where all this 'defining masterpiece' stuff is coming from i don't know. there's nothing here more 'ambitious, combustive, bamboozlingly bombastic' than, say, a five year-old track like Citizen Erased.
i might actually agree with the 9/10 but the critical line DiS and NME and Q among others are going for seems to me out of step with what Muse have actually delivered. look past the band's own hype and what we have here is a (relatively!) stripped down summer pop album. there has been no dramatic leap, and why this would be their 'OK Computer' when OOS and Absolution haven't... well anything's possible, but that doesn't make much sense to me.
I haven't seen any negative reviews
of the new album
maybe
grand works need grand responses? maybe it's brainwashing?
Spot on
I really like the album, but you've hit the nail on the head. Really don't understand why everyone's gone mental over this – 5/5 in Q and Kerrang, 9/10 in NME and on here. As a whole, I'm not sure it works together as well as Absolution, but I much prefer the production on this - when it kicks in, it REALLY kicks in. 8/10 record.
blimey Mikey...
that almost makes me want to listen to the thing.
*almost*, i said... it IS a Muse album after all <shudders>
:)
So the album is getting rave reviews and a heap of praise.
Meh. It's Muse. I expected nothing less. Not as awe-inspiring as Absolution but still a 10/10 from me nevertheless.
Better than Absolution
This has the staying power, and you won't get bored after a few listens. They've surpassed themselves, again.
an alternative review...
I don't quite agree with this review. Try
http://www.kane.karoo.net/review/single/m/museblackholesandrevelations.htm
for an alternative review. Taken from www.audioscribbler.co.uk.
This is a great review!
Spot on, except for one thing.
I disagree about the slow start - Take A Bow is Muse at their most Radiohead-a-like, imo. The repetition of the lyrics, and gradual build to a magnificient crescendo reminds me of Everything In It's Right Place and Sit Down. Stand Up. It's just utterly marvellous.
And Starlight - that's just a a single in waiting. Not only is that Muse gone properly 'pop', but it's a proper love song as well. Majestic.
After that, it's all brilliant, in it's own way. Everytime I hear each track, it grows on me a little more, after being initially underwhelmed.
But Supermassive Black Hole - possibly their crowning glory? Not only does it rock fairly hard, but it has an amazing pop sensibility.
It's like the Disco at the end of the Universe. Brilliant!
How it isn't in line for a 'Crazy'-esque stay at the top of the charts I don't know. It pisses all over that annoying track!
This album is a disapointed
perhaps i was expecting too much,but this is a let down.
Everything on this album has been used on another of their albums (to the point that the feedback at the end of track 1 is identical to the start of Plug in Baby).
It's not that this album is poor, it's not, it's just that if you've heard another either of the past 2 muse full LP releases you won't be surprised by this.
It's predictable "experimental" rock music, that whilst enjoyable on one level, in having fantastic production and catchy choruses, is completly unsatisfying on another, in being effectively a rehash of their earlier work. I am completly surprised at the amount of praise thrown on this album.
err, *disapointment
</drunk>
To say
that this album is better than origin of symmetry is utter tripe. it's mediocre, with one or two flashes of brilliance. Its about as safe as muse could play it. Dissapointing.
that song - knights of cydonia
belongs in a circus, rousing the rabble, as the horses charge around the ring, and the acrobats fling themselves into each others arms.
Ruined ?
this awesome music is distracted from the thom yorke impersonater; he's good at his craft, but i dont enjoy him. it would be much better without him.
Not on Your Furtado
Thom Yorke impersonator? I don't think so. Thanfully Muse have stuck with, and immeasurably improved upon, making great music, unlike Thom who has a permanent residence at the Pretentious Inn. Have you heard his (don't call it Solo) album? Up his own arse or what?
You are right to comment on that they originated very much from RH's earlier sound but they have moved on so much from then..
lol @ you.
hmmmm
yeah you're right "Muse" are definately better than Radiohead.......
?
Are you still labelling them Radiohead rip-offs?
Move on dear, that was 5 years ago....
haha
brilliant
I know...
It's been four fucking albums since then I swear :|
brilliant album
good review. Muses best album for sure
Its good enough
haven't listened to it too much but i think Starlight is crap
i pity the foo
who raggeth starlight...
It sounds like Mew,
Well, the synths anyway.
F*** IT
open your mind to : Diableros; bleed your soul. let it flow. enough said. maybe not; brill.? maybe.
diableros
HA, HA; with affection, i love you all!i hope you all love me too!
silver jews
oh, i forgot about my mama, shame.
ack
I kinda liked a few tracks by Muse from the first album and I bought the second album on the strength of the 'Newborn' single, but I only really started listening to Muse about a month or so ago. I've only just bought Absolution! I shall be going out and buying the new album first thing tomorrow; the tracks I've heard so far have been cracking. Invincible in particular stood out
Buh
This review is crap.. It's just a big hype-thing. The one at audioscrobbler is way better..
There's one thing I do agree on with the reviewer, and that's that 'Black Holes and Revelations' is Muse' 'OK Computer'. But the reviewer thinks this for all the wrong reasons..
I'm not going to tell you why the guy's wrong. Just download the album which won't take long with a decent broadband connection. It's quite varied, with a lot of bass-pumping rock-songs and mediocre lyrics, which is made up for by their presentation. Many people will call it over-produced which I perfectly understand. I'll think I'll even agree on that. But maybe that's JUST what I like about this album. It's a pumped up version of everything they've done before. Muse at hyperspeed, Muse on amphetamine, call it what you want..
hmmm
how about people actually buy the album rather than downloading it?
if this review is 'hype', then the definition of hype has changed significantly from what i know it as.
I will buy this album
but still say the artwork is pisspoor Floyd (same graphic designer) but then look at Pet Sounds!
Nice review
Why am I still in 'meh' mode when it comes to Muse? For everybody else they seem to be musical Marmite, and yet I remain indifferent
I wanna either love them or hate them dammit!
listen to origin of symmetry...
you'll soon be a lover...
i hate muse
Matt 'craig' Bellamy looks like a ferret.
i don't like his singing voice.
i don't like the songs.
i won't be buying this album.
no...
no no no no no no!
I hate this album.
There, I said it. I hate tracks:
4. Map of the Problematique
5. Soldier's Poem
6. Invincible
7. Assassin
and several more. That's 4 bad songs in a row. Not good, folks.
And this isn't progress. They sound very similar to Muse from 1 album ago, 2 albums ago, etc.
do you REALLY like Jack Johnston?
I honestly don't understand
why you lot love Muse so much. They irritate me beyond belief.
Someone..
..Got and A+ in English I bet.
But to be honest some of us more common folk (i.e me) just wanna know two things.
1) Does this album rock?
2) Should I part with my money and buy a copy?
"The album’s rear end is characterised by splashes of Morricone-coloured embellishment, each tiny facet of sound comprising an essential piece of this puzzling album"?????
Yeah sure..err..whatever you say mate.
haha
That made me larf a fair bit.
that's DiS, or 'toss' speak
a mandatory tool in the DiS staffers arsenal. naaaa i'm only joking, Diver writes good articles, this ones just a bit too exciteable for an album that isn't half as exciting as the review makes out.
Superb review
And such an incredible album. Although, like Radiohead's OK Computer, the album before is slightly better.
Fantastic album
And still not their best. They can never top Origin Of Symmetry, no matter how good each subsequent akbum is. I'd certainly rate this above Absolution though, and I can't wait to see them perform it live.
lol
a bit fat lol in your face for that comment. The Bends is so meh in retrospect, and Absolution is a big pile of formulaic over-dramatic, "remember that really good synth bit in Bliss, well i've put it in a few more songs because I'm an uninspired tosser" style shite.
Downloading this one as we speak, if it's any good, Muse can have their 30 pieces of silver, if it's toss I'm deleting it. Hopes are not high after the last offering.
"So Meh"
I hate comments like this. They don't mean anything. That's not a personal attack, I just want to know why you feel how you feel to the Bends. I think it's a great album on a par with OK Computer.
random musings...
Just a thought..... why is it that just because it doesn't sound like "typical Muse" it's labelled as crap/dissapointing/not up to standard etc etc. Ok it's not Origin of Symmetry or Absolution but GOOD JOB...then you'd all be moaning it sounds the same as previous efforts. Excellent album, excellent review. It's new, Bellamy's vocals are varied and as amazing as ever with each song growing on you the more you listen to it. I likes it, i likes it a lot *nods* good on ya Muse, keep em coming :)
undecided
about this album really..which i wasn't expecting..i thought i would adore it, just as i adore all their previous efforts. i need to see tracks from it live.
muse new disc
1.-origin of symmetry
2.-showbiz
3.-disc one hullaballo
4.-absolution
5.............
........................................................................... this disc i dont like.im very confused and belive whit all fans too............
He
is funny looking though isn't he?
It's like
the disco at the end of the world?
What a shit disco! With sticky floors and everything.
I don't want to hear the album, ever. I have heard the single though! And guess what? It stinks! Muse take bad MOR rock, add some quasi-classical prog dump and wear silly proto-futurean outfits with spiky hair. Maybe the kiddlets love it, not me. Boring. The only difference between muse and other shit bands are Bellamy's classical influences. Don't get me wrong at all, classical music is amazing. But when you take the same three chord progressions, add them to shockingly average songs then you come up with the sound of a bunch of tossdogs.
ladies and gents i give you Muse!
Don't take it to seriously
We all enjoy many bands with differing styles depending on your mood. Muse is just one of them for some. Some people attack Muse like they are the only fucking band on the planet, and are force to listen. Blackholes etc, is a very enjoyable album. Yes i think Muse have created a more commerical album (by Muse standards that is). And I say why not. Indie snobs(love that expression) would have them slaves to their selfish minority for only a few scheckles. A more accessible album could introduce new fans, curious about finding a few gems in their back catalog.
A good review should contain very little references to other bands sounds. Such references are almost completely irrelevant to most people. Especially if you unfamilar with the Bands that are a source of reference. Radioheads references are only relevant to those familar etc . I think it can be a bit off putting. I believe an album should be reviewed in the context of the current "popular" musical landscape. What are Muse offering in 2006. Good riff based bands have been lacking. Guitar bands are making a resurggence but, the Darkness for example are 70's Queen rehash. The 80's has reard its head in The Killers and Franz Ferdinand. Even Oasis rode on the wave of the Beatles anthology at the time.
Muse Hmmm, its maybe a bit prog but, not as we know it. Muse sound like Muse thats it. And as you scan the current top 40 UK charts, the choice can be a little bland. I don't care how many records u sell, its bums on seats that really count. The great bands have all been able to deliver LIVE. So over the coming months I think Blackholes and Revelations the stage production, seasoned with favorites from OoS and Absolution. Will in 2006 be something to see. Well done Muse.