Drowned in Sound

Search



Rough Trade
no votes
?
by Ben Yates
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 03/07/2006
  • Label: Mute

Another year brings another Rough Trade compilation, an attempt to pigeonhole the artists that define a genre or a movement, a compilation showcasing the innovation contained within music. This latest offering focuses on singer songwriters at the top of their game – from the unknown to the more established, the double album spanning 41 tracks is bound to throw up some real gems, and in true compilation fashion, some duffers too.

Singer songwriters have always been special in the music industry, their emotion able to pluck at every heart string with every wistful word, the stripped down nature of each song that is able to convey emotion better than any extravagant multi-layered string section. Here, we have a number of these songs, some found from delving deep into the archives, and some obvious choices – the classics that you know and love already. Setting the ball rolling is Micah P Hinson, his deep and husky voice sounds stunning against instruments seamlessly combining country and folk in an exodus of musical talent. Soon after follows Bright Eyes, one of the better known artists on the compilation who has a back catalogue of stunning alt-country songs. Unfortunately though, he pales in comparison to the other artists. It’s not that 'The Calendar Hung Itself' is particularly bad, but when every track that follows is consistent in showcasing the songwriters at their best, it feels out of place – this is not Bright Eyes’ greatest moment.

Elsewhere, there are some real hidden gems. Adrian Crowley is one to watch out for; the Irish songwriter armed with an electric guitar is the perfect soundtrack for going to sleep, and that’s meant in the best possible way. In the same way, King Creosote is a brilliant addition, his inclusion designed to get you hooked on his work. Cat Power’s Metal Heart is a fantastic introduction for listeners unaware of her work, and the other notably brilliant female songwriter PJ Harvey showcases her 'Dress' demo, a recording almost as good as the version featured on Dry. Elliott Smith’s ‘Needle In The Hay’ reminds us why we loved him in the first place, and Antony And The Johnsons‘Cripple And The Starfish’ is as brilliant as the title suggests.

Don’t pick this album up for the big names though, it’s the reputable artists who are relatively unknown that deserve the attention, and these are the songwriters that make this album fulfilling. For instance, little-known Scotish folk musician James Yorkston shines on this album, proof if any that it's the smaller artists that make this album worth the 8 its given. Likewise, those unaware of Richard Thompson's folk rock will take pleasure in being introduced to his work via Vincent Black Lightning 1952, the mellow song featured here is perfect for warm Summer nights. Anyone willing to seek out some new artists for the summer should buy this compilation; you will definitely find some gems worthy of your attention.

  • Various 8 / 10

nice review but....

james yorkston..."little known?"... fence collective member and signed to domino isn't he!? Maybe I'm wrong but I thought he and his athletes were *fairly* well known...

but as I say, nice work otherwise.


james yorkston..."little known?"

Compared to:

PJ Harvey
Cat Power
Elliot Smith
Bright Eyes (spit)
Antony & The Johnsons.................
............................errr yes


Well, for

DiS, he's litlle-known. Alot of people reading won't have heard of him, whereas artists like Bright Eyes are more popular.


and thanks for the kind

words anyway!


the bright ones one is a strange choice

for inclusion on this, yes. i'd have thought someone from Lifted would've been more obvious, but in it's defence it's certainly one of his more powerful tracks.

also, why are these Rough Trade Shops compilations always numbered 01 when they never actually do follow ups to them? ;)


heh.

Maybe ONE day they'll follow them up.... one day.....


the calendar hung itself is probably my favourite bright eyes song

apart from teh one about a girl being like a basketball. thats the best.


Technically...

This is....

An old cd that is being reviwed now.

Can we send in old reviwes of stuff? There are loads of old albums i'd love to review, especially compilations. Like Pure Soft Metal, Shine 9 and Pan Pipe Moods.


Said 3rd July

on the press release ;)


yeah, third of july

NINETEEN NINETY TWO.
disgraceful.


Then why

have i had a copy of it for so long..? Hmmm... those pirates.. or those delightful pre releases.


Wut?

No Jack Johnson or James Blunt?


A few observations...

Firstly, adumcs- if all u wanted to do was be a nitpicking little scrotum then try emailing pitchfork. Secondly, great to read a review that isn't jumping up and down for kudos like a stage school student with adhd. Finally, Shine 9 is well overdue a reappraisal and i feel that these pages are the ideal place. Thank you.


how come

this album wasnt released by rough trade? being that its a rough trade comp n all.. weird, no?


Hmmm... not sure

But all the Rough Trade comps have been released via Mute so far.


it's not a Rough Trade comp

it's a Rough Trade shops comp.

Rough Trade shops have their own 7" label as well, but for these to make financial sense (particularly with the licensing and royalties involved), it makes more sense to go through Mute.


fair enough

.


and

because Rough Trade shops and Rough Trade Records are completely seperate companies and have been for about 20 years now.


The 2005 compilation...

...came out through V2, not Mute.
Innit.


SHINE 9 WAS AMAZING!

i played that to death.
it had everyone.

almost as good as the brit awards double album of 96...