I'm From Barcelona: they're not, but let's move on. You'll spend many early listens of Let Me Introduce My Friends with the creeping paranoia that somewhere, behind a rock or perhaps an overweight hipster, there is a sniper with his crosshairs trained squarely on your fleshy temples. Because I'm From Barcelona could so easily be the world's biggest in-joke, reeling in Pitchforkers and hangers-on alike with songs about stamp collections and treehouses, joyful poppy arrangements and 29 Swedish members with a whole load of clumsy, cutesy second-hand English.
The reality is that Let Me Introduce My Friends is piled high with light-hearted pop drenched in gang choruses, and lies somewhere between The Polyphonic Spree and Architecture In Helsinki. There are artilleries of instruments, wave after wave of handclaps and lyrics channelled straight from the jumbled multi-coloured brain of your average seven-year-old, and it's all strikingly familiar. It seems backward to take issue with the mass production of joy, but man cannot live by banjos, whistles and lollipops alone. There's no end of motley collections of young men and women touting this kind of concentrated pop happiness, and I'm From Barcelona seem content to mingle with their contemporaries instead of attempting to distinguish themselves from them.
This isn't to say their mingling skills aren't admirable: 'Treehouse' lasts five minutes, and while we learn very little during its duration (we're told, for example, that they have built a treehouse - any other details are somewhat sketchy) it's nevertheless a lovingly built stomp lined with harps, banjos and the kind of chorus that lingers in your bones for days and weeks. 'We're From Barcelona' isn't nearly as guiltily enjoyable as it is when accompanied by its video, but the insistent horn-led melody and layers upon layers of warm chorus are just enough to sway affection.
But all too often, I'm From Barcelona are either forgettable or just beyond cloying. 'Collection of Stamps' is one talking dinosaur away from being a children's television theme tune, and its lyrics don't suggest otherwise: "I've got one from Spain and two from Japan / I've got a couple from Israel and Azerbadjan / I've got a plenty from Poland but none from Sudan / Or from Fiji or Uzbekistan." 'This Boy' is a rather drab and impossibly fey number assisted by fellow countryman Emil Svanangen of Loney, Dear, and 'Rec & Play' suffers a similarly high-pitched fate. The gentle petering out that comes with 'The Saddest Lullaby' draws a frail line under this uneven collection: its heart is in the right place, but very little else is.
They're a fantastic, fun live band
And the record's okay, but I agree it's received more praise than it's due. It's just a shame that the power Pitchfork seem to have mean that when they give a very positive review to an album from a relatively unknown band, quite often you find subsequent reviews seem to actually take that one opinion into the consideration of music that was recorded long before the hype machine began rolling.
I agree
with your Pitchfork remark. I've had the album since May and have been in love with it since then, so pre-dated any Pitchfork 'hype', and was then pleasantly surprised when they gave it a good review. Unfortunately other sites seem to have some kind of jealousy towards Pitchfork, and so tied in with this love/hate band it's always going to stir up feelings. Another site I ocassionaly look at, cokemachineglow.com, again mentioned Pitchfork and even said that their/his review was giving it a lower mark as a result of it. Bloomin' ridiculous.
Anyway, great album, and amazingly fun live band as said above. & super nice people too. Another thing I never understand is reviewers wondering whether something is a big joke that they need to be paranoid about. It's music, made (as the album title suggests) by a (big) bunch of friends, nothing more sinister than that.
That review
hardly justifies a 5 though, does it?
It's a bit Pitchfork - writing a rather positive review, but giving it a 5.
Perhaps
A 7.12 rating is more appropriate
i wouldn't say it's 'rather positive'.
considering 10 is absolutely the most perfect and flawless album you can ever hope to hear, i think 5 is fair enough.