Jamie T, Les Incompetents and - soon, you'd hope - The Maccabees. Why do all of London's best indie-pop bands take what seems like an age to release their debut records? For another of the capital's premier jangle-merchants the end is nigh, so to speak. Is it worth crossing our digits in the hope that Good Shoes' lifespan won't be over before it begins?
Spiky guitars? Check. Tight, metronomic drumming? Check. Leafy London accent? What d'you reckon? Musically, Think Before You Speak is Wire's Pink Flag as aped by The TV Personalities; scorned, bored boy sentiment rising like steam from the busy cogs of efficient guitar work and an ice-pick rhythm section. More recently, you could perhaps throw comparisons at trebly chart-botherers like Razorlight and The Futureheads, but things here are really too modest to make those stick. Good Shoes lack the dumb vanity of the former and the circus-act tightness of the latter, happy enough to settle instead for the same lyrical innocence that makes The Maccabees sound like bewildered, SATS level schoolboys.
So many comparisons, but it’s a level of sonic uniformity on this record that challenges you to define Good Shoes on any other terms but their own. That's where the Wire reference comes from - they're by no means a like-for-like match but the guitar sound on their respective records is 'blanket'; ever-present and unfaltering. They clearly have a strong idea of what their music should sound like, so you try to pick it apart for the influences that convinced them. Listen to the first track, 'Nazanin', and you’ll have the blueprints; the code cracked. Bitter guitars chime and clang at least as satisfyingly as they do for all those listed above, but after half an hour of this it seems like Good Shoes are just plagiarising themselves, and playing that should be forthright and confident starts to fade and feel like camouflage. The album plateaus and, in the absence of peaks and troughs, interest begins to wane.
Dismissal out of hand would be unfair, though, until you consider the other half of Good Shoes’ personality. The jagged edges of the music are slotted into place by lyrics that strip everything down to its most basic level – the record’s opening refrain, again in 'Nazanin', does, deliberately or not, amount to something of a motto for a band whose truth gets to the point, quickly.
"All of my insecurities / are summed up / when you walk into my room”.
There's no time for metaphors, or smoke and or for mirrors – just faithful re-imaginings of bedroom anxiety, or of broken hearts, or whinging phone calls from old school friend Keira Knightley. Multi-millionaire, Hollywood heart-throb, ex-Raynes Park high schoolgirl Keira Knightley.
When you listen to a band navigate their way round the sharp end of life, armed with nothing but the truth it is, well, disarming. It’s what makes this record ‘teenage’ and half of the songs on it charming and lucid instead of obvious and alien. 'Morden', 'Small Town Girl' and the stunning 'Never Meant To Hurt You' stand out from the pack and once the melodies take root in your head you realise that this is modern guitar-pop in the purest of forms. A good record then, though one that could undoubtedly have been improved if they’d been brave enough to shear it of a few tracks and watch it clock in at around 20 minutes. Maybe then we wouldn't have had to wait so long for the damn thing.
This is a
really good record in that it does what it says on the tin, nothing more nothing less, and is jam packed with tunes.
This is a good album
But I fear that this and The Maccabees album are too weak on killer hits to really break out of their current state.
Prove me wrong, world. Go on.
small town girl isn't about keira knightley
rhys the lead singer dismissed the rumour. disappointing.
i like the album, and i liked that review.
I agree with domgourlay.
I like this band and the album for the reasons that it is trying to do nothing more than it appears. Just solid, well structured music, that brings a smile to my face. On the technical side, I think they play some nice intertwining guitar lines, backed up with solid bass and drums throughout.
Thought they were enjoyable at Reading Festival last year too.
All I can say is, I hope they can keep up with the fast moving music trends because I fear that spiky guitar music is on its way out, with electro indie stuff filling the void
I think you are
just right in the review...I think that an intereseting live band has got their demos into a perfect album. Yet could there have been more??
Thats all I am wondering.
I find the chap's
rather annoying. Although in principle I like them.
They do
good adverts.
this makes
the record sound shit.
It does a bit.
I went to see them last night, I fully intend to buy this. They were so good, shame about the whole 14-15 year old mass following.
its fun
that they have a young following. its a mature album sonically and lyrically. i like it. 7or8 i reckon.
I guess it did give me and friends
something to laugh at. There was a boy wearing white sunglasses happily bopping away.
I feel 17 again
listening to these guys.
I think they're great.
ugh
i've been waiting so long for this album, & i find it veeeery difficult to like to re-do's of their demos. the 3rd version of 'all in my head' is by far the worst. 'in the city' just pales compared to the demo as does 'small town girl'.
i need to stop listening to the demos, early singles, & perhaps then i'll like the proper release.... )=
although kubichek!'s forking rocks....
Really like this
'Small Town Girl' sounds so fresh, definately my fave so far.
Smiley
I think this review is spot on. It's not trying to be something it's not just a good album. It might not be the first one you grab in a moment of musical passion however there will be a time when you just fancy a bit of Good Shoes and there it'll be with a little cheeky grin on it's face :)