As difficult to believe as it may be, for a few short months in 1998 Air were viewed as the French electronic equivalent of punk rock, such was the ecstatic fervour that greeted their arrival on the UK scene, an arrival that seemed to coincide with the timely demise of Britpop.
Of course, what no one realised at the time was that Air only ever really had one idea between them, and therefore would only make one record of note followed by a series of sound-alike offerings over the next (almost) decade, not one of which quite matched up to the initial buzz of Moon Safari.
There is also the small fact that Air stole muzak away from the dinner party circuit and into the indie clubs, along with a whole host of generic copyists snoozing their way through album after album of sonic wallpaper.
What most people casually forget is Nicolaus Godin and JB Dunckel do occasionally experiment with their minimalist sound every once in a while, and the fact they've roped producer extraordinaire Nigel Godrich in for Pocket Symphony would suggest their intention was to aim for something a little different, even if the end result merely resembles more of the same.
They've also managed to get Jarvis Cocker and Neil Hannon to add vocals to a couple of the songs here, the latter's 'Somewhere Between Waking And Sleeping' winning the foppish over-40s war of the poseurs.
Elsewhere there is little to get excited about, although the swoonsome 'Photograph' and futuristic 'Mer Du Japon' at least bring Air a bit closer to the present, as obvious nods to the likes of Maps and Hearts Of Black Science make for an interesting diversion from the par de course.
Unfortunately, I cannot imagine myself listening to this record unless I was decorating the living room or tiling the bathroom and needed some kind of background distraction to ensure I didn't bunk off early to watch Melanie Sykes.
File under "Music for Somnambulists". Next...
This is Godrich's third time working with Air
Begone bawbag, you know jack
Where does it say
in the review that it isn't?
My only suggestion was that maybe getting him involved on this record with along with a different "panel" of guest vocalists might herald something different. Obviously not, bawbag...
air = boring coffee table
music for people who think that including air in their feeble collection makes them have a varied music taste.
Air Live = Yawn
I am in the minority (though there are some on this site) who believe their second abum proper, 10000 Hertz Legend, is a magnificenly underrated work.
Saw them live the other week. Tedium. And an audience of Grade A fuckwits.
ive still not heard 10000Hz
supposedly it's up his own arsehole.. but i like the artwork
Really?
I'm wondering where it was you saw them. Since I saw them live also in the last month and they were really surprisingly intense. An audience is an audience and shouldn't detract from the music unless you're stuck in a circlejerk, but where I was there was nothing but love for those onstage.
The new album is probably their worst, all truth told - and previously I'd have said 10,000 Hz was, but that grew on me over a long period of time. Pocket Symphony just has too many 'by numbers' moments - the good stuff really sparkles (Photograph, Mer du Japon) in comparison, but the Jarvis track is the single dullest thing either artist has been involved in.
You are so wrong!
This is a wonderfully subtle album. I'm not surprised so many people don't get it. It's not really pop at all. But much of it is beautiful. And they're great live too! When I saw them last Charlotte Gainsbourg joined them for an encore: wonderful!
I do wonder tho, if Air made a double length cd of the best tracks from Charlotte Gainsbourg's album, Darkel's album and Pocket symphony, this would be a really amazing album.
I reckon 10000 Hz Legend is the best air album, which was criticised at the time for having too many ideas. And it sounds absolutely nothing like Moon Safari or Talkie Walkie or Premieres Symptomes. I wonder if this reviewer actually has heard these albums because saying "Air only ever really had one idea between them, and therefore would only make one record of note followed by a series of sound-alike offerings over the next (almost) decade" is just lazy journalism.
A bit harsh
One good album?
There is plenty of good albums from these guys that more than live up to expectations. Talkie Walkie, 10,000Hz Legend and this one. Yeah, Pocket Symphony.
And what exactly is wrong with having more of the same? Especially since everybody loves Moon Safari, why not more of that music? If you want something different go listen to another artist.
5 out of 10 my ass.